Why is Wrightsoft so, complicated, to use and expensive? To do a simple block load calc, The old…
Discussion · Sep 8, 2026
Why is Wrightsoft so, complicated, to use and expensive? To do a simple block load calc, The old version of CoolCal, I have found to be fast reliable and very user friendly. And its ACCA approved. Another thing that kills me with manual J, D, S, books is they make some descriptions broad that they can't be reliable when if something did go wrong. Or when they leave it up to the local jurisdiction. To me the local jurisdiction can override any code if they wanted to anyhow. Thoughts?
Replies
Reply · Sep 8, 2026
Well, wrightsoft and elite had a stranglehold on the market for so long. I will say it also takes a lot of time / money / energy to manage a software project, so it's not free or magic like people tend to portray. I personally also prefer the legacy version of CoolCalc for my loads, but I've sort of built my workflows around it.
Reply · Sep 19, 2026
By legacy, are you referring to the trace format?
Reply · Sep 19, 2026
Been years since I’ve used writesoft, but kwikmodel3d is a much more affordable and easier option
Reply · Sep 22, 2026
If you're looking for options for simple block load calcs, I've really been enjoying Conduit Tech. It has limited function compared to Wrightsoft as it only does Manual J, and it is more expensive, but I can spit out a Manual J with a 3D rendering of the home in about 25-30 minutes depending on the size of the home. It's a great tool, but like great tools, you pay for them.
Reply · Oct 31, 2026
From the software side, this is a familiar pattern: a tool built to cover every job — Manual J, D, S, drawings, reports — ends up feeling heavy when you only need one simple block load. You're paying for the whole package, and wading through setup you don't need that day.
For a simple block load, I'd use the simplest tool that does that one job well and is ACCA-approved. CoolCal already worked for you, so that's your benchmark. Before you trust a new one on a paying job, run the same house through both and compare. If the numbers land close, keep the simple one for block loads and save the heavy tool for the jobs that actually need it. And jot your assumptions — design temps, infiltration, duct location — right on the calc, so the number can be checked later instead of argued about.
Member names and profile links appear after sign-in. Details written in posts and photos may still identify people. Sign in to join the discussion.