There are many great diagnostic tools available to the service technician today, but I shaven’t found a tool as versatile than the simple isolation diagnosis.
There are many ways this concept can be applied but let’s start with some examples so you get what I mean.
Low Voltage Short Circuit Isolation Diagnosis
You arrive on a no cooling service call at a home and you find the system is off and doesn’t respond to any thermostat settings. You check the breaker and the condensate switch at the furnace by force of habit and look at the door switch, everything looks in order so far.
You take a look at the 3A low voltage fuse and SURE ENOUGH, visually blown.
Now there are many schools of thought of how to proceed from here but I prefer to use logical possibilities and process of elimination before starting to tear everything apart.
First, look at any possible rub out points on low voltage wires in the furnace, visually inspect the safeties, go outside and check the control wire both inside and outside the condensing unit and ESPECIALLY wherever wires run across copper tubing. If you find nothing at these common failure points I will pull open the thermostat there and check that it’s wired correctly with no exposed copper.
You will notice that I didn’t just “replace the fuse”, because science and experience has shown me that fuses don’t just fail open on their own.
If I still find nothing then the “logical possibilities” part of the diagnosis has ended and we move into the isolation diagnosis part of our testing.
Some techs prefer disconnecting all the low voltage wires at the furnace and ohming them one at a time to ground and common at this point. Sometimes this works but I prefer to let the system work for me rather than pulling apart all the wires at this stage.
I replace the blown fuse with a 3a re-settable fuse / breaker like the one shown above with the thermostat off in all modes (to keep from wasting fuses). I then close the door switch and see if the fuse blows, if it does not then we can determine that there isn’t a continuous short circuit in R.
I then use a jumper wire and connect each switch leg (G,Y,W,O,W2,Y2 etc…) to the R terminal quickly and see if any of them trip the fuse or throw a spark (remember this is 24v it’s not going to hurt you). Often you will find the circuit with the short just that simply and then you can further isolate until to find the exact part of the circuit causing the issue.
Let’s say the Y circuit is the one blowing the fuse, you can then separate the two wires going to the condenser and the thermostat and tap one side at a time to R, if the conductor going outside is the one throwing the big spark / blowing the fuse then that is the direction to focus. You then go outside and disconnect the Y wire at the condenser wire nut or terminal block. If the short continues you know it is in the wire between the condenser and the furnace and not in the condenser. If it continues then you know it is in the condenser or in the contactor itself.
Shorted Compressor Isolation Diagnosis
Compressors shorted to ground or “grounded” is a pretty common diagnosis in the field and leads to an expensive compressor or system replacement. It’s important that we get that diagnosis correct and take away all the guess work so I use a combination of diagnostic tools and isolation diagnosis to ensure I never get it wrong.
When I walk up to a condensing unit and it has a tripped breaker, the first thing I do is reset it and see what happens…
NO IT ISN’T
The breaker tripped for a REASON and every time I reset that breaker I run the risk of creating a major arc. If that short is inside the compressor I add carbon and acid to the refrigerant every time I reset that breaker.
So once again we FIRST perform a full visual inspection of all the high voltage wires, terminals, contactor, capacitor, crankcase heater and the breaker itself. If that all looks OK then we pull the top and inspect the compressor leads and terminals themselves. Before you go pulling on the terminals or compressor plug make sure you are wearing gloves and safety glasses, it is possible for one of those terminals to blow out of the fusite at that moment and freeze your face or hands.
Another quick tip is take a photo of all wires and/or tag them before pulling them off. We all have cameras in our pockets nowadays which makes mis-wiring upon reassembly a thing of the past (I wish).
Now measure resistance to ground (In this case the copper stubs on the compressor) from each terminal. It is OK to use a megohmmeter if you want, just keep in mind that some compressors are still considered “good” by the manufacturer all the way down to 0.5 megaohms and some meters say “bad” at 20 megaohms.
Once you are certain as you can be that the compressor short to ground is the culprit or if it is reading between 0.5 and 20 megaohms to GROUND making you unsure I have one more task for you.
Now ISOLATE the compressor by taping and strapping up the plug or terminals so they aren’t touching anything. Now reassemble the unit and reset the breaker.
If it doesn’t trip and everything else (Condenser fan motor etc..) runs properly then you can feel good about your diagnosis, if it trips again then it’s back to the drawing board.
Isolation diagnosis can be used in things like finding system noises and even in finding open circuits by using jumper wires. Isolation diagnosis is taking a hypothesis and testing it with one component or conductor at a time allowing you to find the culprit through process of elimination.
On communicating systems where I wanted to be SURE it was the controller and not the wire I removed the controller from the wall and wired it directly to the fan coil board to make sure it still didn’t work even with no wire between. Sometimes my hypothesis was right and sometimes it was wrong but either way isolation diagnosis has saved me from looking dumb on many occasions.
P.S. – Bert Made this video a while back using isolation diagnosis to find a LV short
Bryan Orr is a lifelong learner, proud technician and advocate for the HVAC/R Trade