Why the 20° Rule is Driving The Internet Crazy
Every year when outdoor temperatures rise there is a rash of news stories and articles about air conditioning. We had an early heat wave this year and lot of people have come out and referred to the idea of a rule of thumb of what temperature you can achieve indoors based on the outdoor temperature, most commonly used is the “20° rule”. Here is a link to an article like this.
There is no such thing as a universal 20° rule, it is simply the difference between the indoor and outdoor design conditions and it varies based on location and design
There are times where 20° is the design difference between indoor and outdoor temperatures, specifically when the design outdoor temperature is 95° and indoor is 75° for cooling. Before we go any further let’s specify EXACTLY what we are talking about
This is all about designing an air conditioning system and has nothing to do with DIAGNOSING it. When a tech goes to a home their job is to diagnose and test the HVAC system not to quote rules of thumb.
When a contractor designs an air conditioning system they have to size it for the space being cooled (I’m just going to focus on cooling here). The size of the unit needs to be based on a design indoor and outdoor temperature and humidity.
The indoor temperature design for homes is fixed by ACCA at 75° and the designer can choose 45%, 50% 0r 55% indoor design humidity.
The outdoor design temperature comes from temperature data specific to the location and is based on a temperature that will only be (statistically) exceeded 1% or 0.4% of the time in that location.
We do not design air conditioning systems for the hottest possible day with the lowest possible indoor temperature the customer may want because that would result in over-sizing for 99.6% of the year and over-sizing isn’t a good thing for many reasons including –
- Higher initial cost
- Larger Ducts Required
- Poor humidity control
- Short Cycling resulting in less efficiency and shorter system life
- Generally lower rated efficiency on larger capacity systems
Take a look at the chart above, you can see from a glance that Florida has outdoor design conditions of 90° to 95° depending on the city and which column you use for design. Because the indoor design conditions stay fixed at 75° regardless the design difference on a peak design day vary from 20° down to as low as 15°.
Nevada (for example) is completely different –
You can see Reno is much like Florida in terms of dry bub temperature but Las Vegas is 106° – 108° and still a 75° indoor temperature design so a 31° to 33° difference must be designed for.
ACCA manual J does allow some oversizing to find a proper system match, from 15% greater than the load for straight cooling and 25% greater on heat pump systems (where the heating load is greater than the cooling load) but that isn’t a lot of wiggle room.
It’s also important to remember that system performance also changes based on outdoor and indoor temperatures and we must select out equipment capacity based on the specific design conditions rather than AHRI conditions which are 80° indoor and 95° outdoor temperatures.
So here are some facts to get straight-
- There is no universal design rule of thumb
- This 20° rule has no relationship to the old 20° delta T rule (which is also a bad rule of thumb)
- Oversizing isn’t a good idea ESPECIALLY in humid climates
- The fact that you can get your home to certain temperature in one part of the county has nothing to do with another location
- How cold you can get your house on a hot day is just a representation of the capacity of your system in comparison to the load, it’s not something to be proud of.
- Did I mention that over-sizing isn’t a good thing? Just because you can get your house to 66° on a 140° degree day in Nome, Alaska doesn’t mean you have a better air conditioner. It means someone put in a unit that is much too large.
So when a contractor emails their clients before a heat wave (Like I did recently) or when a LOCAL news channel runs a story and quotes something like, “You can expect your home to maintain only 20° lower inside than the outdoor temperature” withhold judgement for a minute and consider. That 20° rule may be a good guideline for their market and they may be telling it to consumers to reduce nuisance service calls on a rare 100° day in a place like Savannah where the design temperature is 93°.
As HVAC professionals we understand that some designs will do better than others and with modern multi-stage / variable speed systems we can get away with a little more over-sizing than we used to. We also (should) know that we size systems based on heat gain and loss and not based on square footage and that oversizing a system because the customer wants it like a “meat locker” has unintended consequences.
Now there will always be the techs who use silly rules of thumb rather than proper diagnosis procedures. If a customer calls you to look at their A/C don’t just walk up to the thermostat and say something like “It’s 80° in here and 100° outside so it’s doing good”. You need to properly test the equipment and I would suggest doing actual capacity calculations using in duct psychrometers and MeasureQuick in addition to everything else if it seems like the system just isn’t keeping up.
Check the charge, check ducts and insulation, do a good job of making sure everything is as it should be for the customer…. but sometimes, on unusually hot days, a properly designed and installed system may bot maintain 75° inside.
So these are my takeaways –
- Size systems properly not based on rules of thumb
- Still use proper system diagnosis and commissioning. Don’t use a rule of thumbs as an excuse not to do a proper diagnosis.
- It’s OK to use a rule of thumb specific to your market to communicate with customers so long as it’s based on real design conditions
- Don’t oversize systems especially in humid climates
- Don’t be a jerk to people on the internet
So in Orlando… you can expect your A/C to maintain 75° on a 95° day in most cases and if the temperature rises above that it may not keep up.
If you want to know more about the ACCA design process take a look at this quick sheet with design instructions